Mr Ang Hin Kee: To ask the Minister for Defence (a) what has been the response since camera phones were permitted in the Green Zone of 29 selected Singapore Armed Forces camps from September 2012; and (b) what are the types of violations since the implementation and whether the Camp Commander will issue a warning instead of punishment for cases arising from a lack of clarity or understanding of the rules.

Dr Ng Eng Hen: The security zoning system was introduced on 1 September 2012 to allow servicemen to carry camera equipped mobile phones into Singapore Armed Forces (SAF) camps. This facilitates the use of information technology, whilst protecting the security of sensitive information in SAF premises.

To date, a total of 29 SAF camps have been zoned. Under the security zoning system, camp complexes are divided into Red and Green zones. Within the Green Zones, our servicemen are allowed to bring in all models of camera-enabled mobile phones. No camera-enabled devices are allowed in the Red Zones. Unauthorised photography is prohibited in both zones.

Our servicemen are briefed on the importance of maintaining information security and the rules regarding the zoning system. They are regularly reminded on the security zone regulations through Routine Orders, Security Instructions, and physical signage in the camps. National servicemen on in-camp training are reminded of the rules and are aware that unauthorised photography is not allowed in SAF premises. Servicemen who are unclear about the rules have avenues to seek clarifications.

Our servicemen are warned that it is an offence to violate these rules. The severity of punishment is determined on a case by case basis, taking into consideration the extent of security breach and any mitigating factors. The punishments are typically heavier for repeat offenders and those whose violations result in security breaches. With the implementation of the zoning system, the number of servicemen who have been punished for unauthorised carriage of camera phones and unauthorised photography has decreased.

Information security is critical to Singapore's defence. The security zoning system has been well received by our servicemen, and they appreciate the convenience provided to them. We continue to welcome feedback from our servicemen on how to improve the implementation of the zoning system.